Class Sessions

 

Text Reading | Topics | Text Discussion Questions 

At the conclusion of this session please post your discussion questions as a single set of responses under the heading DQ4.

 

Session 4: The Battle for the World Economy Episode One, The Battle of Ideas
 
Reading Assignments: 

Daniel Yergin and Joseph Stanislaw, The Commanding Heights. Video Transcript One.

 

  Discussion Topics:

The social and economic catastrophe left in the ashes of World War I ignited an intellectual and political struggle that would last most of the 20th century -- a battle between the powers of government and the forces of the marketplace over who would control the economies of the world's great nations.

"The Battle of Ideas" tells the story of how, for half a century, the world moved toward more government control -- from the centrally planned economies of the communist world to the "mixed economies" of Europe and the developing world to the United States' regulated capitalism -- and then began to move away.

The ideas of two economists lay at the center of that struggle: John Maynard Keynes, the elegant Englishman who advocated government intervention to control the booms and busts of capitalist economies, and Friedrich von Hayek, the Austrian emmigrant who argued that government intervention in the economy would erode human freedom and was doomed to failure.

In western democracies, Keynes's ideas would dominate for decades, until the economic crises of the 1970s forced political leaders to look for new ideas, and rediscover Von Hayek's theories. In the 1980s, the simultaneous emergence of the conservative governments of Margaret Thatcher and Ronald Reagan, who both embraced Hayek's free-market ideas, set the stage for a worldwide capitalist revolution.

 

 Discussion Questions:

  1. What happens when governments control or dominate a national economy?
  2. Why have most countries in the world turned back toward free-market capitalism after 80 years of experimentation with socialism and communism?
  3. Why did so many socialist economies fail?
  4. What are the benefits and drawbacks of the capitalist economic system?
  5. What happens when command economies transform into market economies? How is the transition best undertaken?