Guidelines for Article Critique
First,
identify the type of research being conducted:
If
it is qualitative, identify:
1. The participant(s)
2. Variable(s)
3. Setting
4. Data
collection methods
5. Type:
ethnographic, case study, grounded theory, participative inquiry or
historical
6. Research
question
7. Data
reduction technique(s)
8. Conclusions
reached
9. Evaluate
the overall strength of the research design, address areas of credibility,
transferability, dependability, confirmability, and authenticity.
You do not need to address all of these areas, only the ones you think
the study may be weak in.
If
it is survey, identify:
1. Identify the
participant(s)
2. Variable(s)
under investigation
3. Extraneous
variable(s)
4. Research
question
5. Research
hypothesis
6. Null
hypothesis
7. Data
collection methods
8. Data
reduction technique(s)
9. Conclusions
reached
10. Evaluate
the overall strength of the research design, i.e.: reliability of
the instrument, generalizability of the results
If
it is causal-comparative or correlational, identify:
1. The participant(s)
2. Variable(s)
and if they are independent or dependent or neither
3. Extraneous
variable(s)
4. Research
question
5. Research
hypothesis
6. Data
collection methods
7. Data
reduction technique(s)
8. Conclusions
reached
9. Threats
to INternal and EXternal validity
10. Evaluate
the overall strength of the research design = How confident can we
be in the results and conclusions presented in the article?
If
it is experimental, quasi-experimental, or single case, identify:
1. The participant(s)
2. Independent
variable(s)
3. Dependent
variable(s)
4. Extraneous
variable(s)
5. Sampling
Method
6. Experimental
group(s)
7. Control
group research question
8. Research
hypothesis
9. Null
hypothesis
10. Research
design (if experimental or quasi, see pages 70-79 of your text; if
single case, see pages 149-154 of your text)
11. Data
collection methods
12. Data
reduction technique(s)
13. Conclusions
reached
14. Threats
to INternal and EXternal validity
15.
Evaluate the overall strength of the research design = How confident
can we be in the results and conclusions presented in the article?
|